Pages

Showing posts with label quinrose. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quinrose. Show all posts

Saturday, February 2, 2013

Manga Review: Alice in the Country of Clover: Cheshire Cat Waltz, Volume 1, by QuinRose and Mamenosuke Fujimaru



Rating (Out of 5): ~3
Publisher: Seven Seas
Spoilers?: No.
Volumes: 7

Goodreads Synopsis:

The sequel to the New York Times bestselling manga Alice in the Country of Hearts

This all-new manga series reimagines Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland in a sly, sexy shoujo style that follows up QuinRose’s New York Times bestselling Alice in the Country of Hearts, but can be read independently. Each new volume is an oversized editions that feature impressive artwork and color pinups

His name is Boris, and despite his human form and piercings and tattoos, he is not your typical punk teenager. For he is the Cheshire Cat, complete with cat ears and a tail, and a penchant for riddles. Boris is in madly love with Alice, and Alice is vulnerable and lonely. But will she fall for the Cheshire Cat?

Available on Amazon.

Review:

I’m kind of unsure what to think about this spin-off.
First of all, I don’t like how the story was changed. In this version, Alice lives in the Amusement Park, and Alice meets Boris differently than she did in the original. Which, I guess, could work alright, but when the book started, it just made me feel confused and like I’d missed something. Like there was a different before this one that I did not read, but I’m pretty sure that’s not the case. It didn’t really help that there was very little back story.
Second, the art is different. Now, I understand that it’s a different artist, and that’s okay, and I’m sure it’s just going to take me a while to get used to. But at the moment, I don’t like this artist as much as I did the first. Mostly it’s okay, but the people look… wider than they should.
Next: the characters are a little out of character at times. Boris, for instance, is not nearly as adorable as he was in the original, or as he should be. I loved Boris in the original, but I feel like he’s going to have to work to earn those feelings back. I’m even a little unsure of how I feel about Alice. Something about her just seems… off to me. Not sure what, but something.
Although, the more I see Julius, the more I love him. His spin-off, which I think is only one volume?, is coming out soon, and I’m really starting to think that I’m going to have to bump it up on my list to read.
The story in this volume was okay. I mostly liked seeing the other characters, but some of them were a little off, and the art was different, and Boris was too pushy. I’m just not really feeling it at the moment, which is a bit of a disappointment, given how much I was looking forward to it. I’m planning on reading a bit more in the series and hoping it gets better.
There was also an excerpt of a different manga at the end of this book, which was probably just shameless advertising, but that’s alright. It was for A Certain Scientific Railgun, which did actually look a bit interesting.

Saturday, January 26, 2013

Manga Review: Alice in the Country of Hearts, Omnibus Volume 3 (#5-6), by QuinRose and Soumei Hoshino



Rating (Out of 5): ~3.5
Publisher: Yen Press (Previously, up to volume 5 [not omnibus], Tokyopop)
Volumes: 6; Omnibus: 3
Spoilers?: Some, including the person she chooses.

Goodreads Synopsis:


Kidnapped by a handsome man with rabbit ears, Alice Liddell finds herself abandoned in an odd place called Wonderland and thrust into a "game," the rules of which she has yet to learn. Alice, ever the plucky tomboy, sets off to explore and get the lay of this strange land, intent on finding her rude kidnapper and giving him a piece of her mind (and her fist). But little does she know that she's wandered right into the middle of a dangerous power struggle involving just about all of Wonderland's attractive, weapon-happy denizens. And the only way for Alice to return home is to get acquainted with the lot of them?! How in the world will she manage that and still manage to stay alive?!


Available on Amazon.

Review:

I’m a little unsure what to think of this volume. Overall, I really like this series, but the ending…
There was the ball, and Alice danced with several people, and she had a fight with Blood, and a talk with Vivaldi. And then there was a fight, and people talking with Nightmare, and talk of how Alice’s glass is almost filled up, and Alice wanting to go home but also going to miss everyone in Wonderland, and then it was time for her to go home, and there were some mediocre goodbyes and some sweet goodbyes and some nonexistent goodbyes. And then she went home, and then she was brought back to Wonderland and her memory was, I think, erased or pushed back, including how she apparently knows everyone, especially Peter, from some other time but Nightmare won’t let her remember.
I want to know how she knows them, what happened, and why Nightmare won’t let her remember. I’m not happy with that being a cliffhanger.
I’m also not sure how I feel about Alice’s going back to Wonderland. I mean, it kind of makes sense, but that can only last so long, and why didn’t she have to choose to go back, and instead just seemed resigned and waited for it to happen, and wasn’t she supposed to bring someone back with her? (Did I just imagine that?) I think I mostly feel uneasy because that’s not how it’s supposed to happen, and that doesn’t seem like a complete ending, and I still have questions left unanswered.
Then there’s the fact that Alice chose Blood, which I had been expecting but am not very happy about. He just… never won me over. I don’t totally trust him, and there were other characters that I liked more.
I’m a little unsatisfied, but I still enjoyed the books. Now I have to think about which spin-off I want to read, or which one I want to start first, given that the answer to which one is: all of them. I’m especially looking forward to the one focused on Boris, and Julius, and I want one to focus on Peter. All three of them have won me over as candidates, with Boris at top and Peter at the bottom. The one to do with the Blood Twins looks good. There's also one with Elliot, and Ace, and a Joker story, but I'm not as excited for those ones.
Now, I guess I’m just looking forward to finding out what happens next in the spin-offs.

Saturday, December 29, 2012

Manga Review: Alice in the Country of Hearts, Omnibus Volume 2 (#3-4), by QuinRose and Soumei Hoshino



Rating (Out of 5): ~3.5 (can be upped to a four)
Publisher: Yen Press (Previously by Tokyopop)
Volumes: 6; Omnibus: 3

Goodreads Synopsis:


Kidnapped by a handsome man with rabbit ears, Alice Liddell finds herself abandoned in an odd place called Wonderland and thrust into a "game," the rules of which she has yet to learn. Alice, ever the plucky tomboy, sets off to explore and get the lay of this strange land, intent on finding her rude kidnapper and giving him a piece of her mind (and her fist). But little does she know that she's wandered right into the middle of a dangerous power struggle involving just about all of Wonderland's attractive, weapon-happy denizens. And the only way for Alice to return home is to get acquainted with the lot of them?! How in the world will she manage that and still manage to stay alive?!


Available on Amazon.

Review:

I am really liking this series. It’s not like a five star, ohmygod this is the most amazing, well written, book I have ever read, but at the moment I would rate it at a very solid, high 3.5, but it’s a very good, very enjoyable 3.5.
Oh, before I really get into this review, I want to say that there will most likely be more spoilers than there were in the first books’ review. In that one, since it was the first in the series, I was trying to be vague; in this one, not as much. I don’t know how detailed I will be, since there is just so much to go over, as so much happens in each book, with two volumes, and I’m not going to go over every little detail; I’m going to keep some of it open and vague, so there’s still the experience of reading the book to look forward to. Also, I do plan on going into detail of each character, especially the love interests.
A lot of this book, much like the first, was just scenes of Alice getting closer to all of the men in Wonderland. And I’m a bit frustrated to say that I kind of really like all of the men. In the first book, I liked some of them and found others cute, but now I’m kind of a fan of almost all of them, and I don’t know what to think of that. I haven’t really read a book before where I actually liked all of the love candidates and could see the heroine with each of them.
In the first book, I found Peter White, the rabbit, to be a bit annoying, and wanted him to back off of Alice, even if some of it was humorous. But then, almost immediately into this book, I saw more of him, and found that his desperate love for Alice was really adorable, and then he turned into his bunny form ‘cause Alice wanted him to, and I just kind of almost love him now. He’s still a bit too pushy for my taste, but he’s adorable.
Then there’s Julius, who I just liked in a simple way in the first book, but now I see is actually a love interest. I like him, and there was one really sweet moment between him and Alice in this book, but I still don’t really think of him as a huge love interest. I mean, I guess it could work, but I see them more as platonic friends, in the way that she could go to him for help, that he’s there for her if she needs him and she would repay the efforts, but not so much in a romantic way. Although, now that I think about it…
Next there’s the hatter, Blood Dupre. He’s not really crazy like I think the hatter should be, but he does seem dangerous and I don’t think I’m a huge fan of him at the moment. Plus, there was this one big moment between him and Alice in this book that was not good, but that I won’t spoil. And then he has this thing with the Queen… So, I’m a tiny bit intrigued, but not too big a fan of him at the moment. I do suspect him to become a bigger contender, though, or something to be revealed about him that is supposed to make me like him in the last book, so we’ll see.
Oh, Elliot March. I like Elliot, he’s sweet and cute, kind of an innocent contender even if he knows how to shoot a gun. I don’t see him as a big romantic interest, either, but I guess it could work. I do like him, and find him rather adorable.
A bit like Elliot and Julius, I actually see even less potential in Gowland. He just doesn’t strike romance, or any kind of heat, in me, and I don’t really think there’s been anything to cause it between him and Alice either. So, I don’t think he’s very big in the competition, so maybe they’re just going to be friendly with each other?
Ah, Ace. In the first book, I really liked him and found him interesting, and was expecting him to become a bigger love interest, to fall for him even more. That is not what happened. Instead, he took a rather dark turn in this book, and now I’m feeling very wary of him. He’s dangerous, and quite crazy, and there’s something very off about him, and I don’t like it. Dangerous in a way that, one wrong move, and he’ll kill you, not even joking. I don’t like it, and I don’t like that I don’t like it. I was actually even expecting something very bad to happen to him in this book, but it didn’t. We’ll see if he gets any better, or worse, in the last book, I guess.
Lastly (kind of), Boris. I love Boris. I found him to be adorable when I first met him, and then there was just something about him that I liked, and those feelings grew by a lot in this book. He is just so freakin’ sweet and adorable and I love him. I want more of him. He is probably my favorite of the group at the moment, even if I doubt he’s even in one of the top spots realistically for who Alice is going to choose.
Now, onto the characters that aren’t in the main guy group. Dee and Dum. Those two are cute little boys, but they are rather dangerous. I like them, but I’m also a bit wary of them, especially after a certain scene between them and Alice in this book that I won’t spoil.
The Queen, Vivaldi. We got to know her a bit more in this book, and I’m kind of ‘eh’y about her. I don’t really mind her, I don’t find her to be too dangerous at the moment (although that could always change), I don’t dislike her, I feel a tiny bit of sympathy and interest toward her. I’m just ‘eh’ about her, mostly. One thing I do like about her, is the way she calls herself ‘we’. I usually find those little eccentricities interesting, and I find it especially works here. I mean, it shows that she holds herself in high regard, but it’s also just a neat tick of hers, and it fits.
And, Nightmare. He, I guess, love Alice as well. He’s not really in the competition, we don’t see very much of him, and I honestly don’t really have much to say about him. I’m pretty sure he’s sick or something, as he’s always coughing up blood, but I don’t know why. Maybe if I got to know him more…
We found out in this book that, I’m assuming, everyone in town gets to dream and speak to Nightmare. Particularly, we see Peter and Julius talking to him, conversing about their wanting Alice and what they want for her in particular, and we see that they all openly know that the other guys are falling for her. Apparently because only someone who everyone would love is able to enter Wonderland? I wasn’t too sure on that, but the whole thing is interesting to me and I hope to find out more.
A lot happened in this book, and it was good, but I’m not going to spoil too much. This book did end off with an invitation to a ball the Queen is hosting, and everyone in town is required to go as part of the Game. Not much more development happened with the Game, though. Mostly the book focused on the characters and some almost-killings, we didn’t get to see how much more filled Alice’s glass is, and she keeps thinking about home while everyone tries distracting her from it, and she keeps telling everyone that she is set on going home, even if that’s maybe not true anymore?
These books are really good, they’re entertaining and also a bit dark, but I feel like the dark element of them should be expanded upon. It just seems like it’s giving us glimpses of the darkness lying in each person, but not fully expanding on it or showing us it, that it’s downplaying it by a lot, when it could be a lot creepier. I wish that it were more creeper, but I am enjoying it nonetheless.
I’m excited to read the next, and last, book, and I’m sure it’ll be good, hopefully even better than the first two, but I am wary. I just don’t see how everything can get cleared up in one(two) volume(s), that doesn’t seem like enough space.
Oh, there was an extra chapter at the end from Alice in the Country of Joker. Mostly, I just don’t see why it was there. It was interesting and all, it did make me intrigued to read the rest of it, given that it ended with Alice agreeing to play a Game with the Joker, but why show us this when we haven’t even finished this series yet? I mean, I know there are a shit ton of spin-off’s of this series (and, yea, I’m already debating which ones I want to read) but you should at least let us finish the original series first.

Saturday, December 22, 2012

Manga Review: Alice in the Country of Hearts, Omnibus Volume 1 (#1-2), by QuinRose and Soumei Hoshino



Rating (Out of 5): ~3.5
Publisher: Yen Press (Previously, though not my editions, TokyoPop)
Spoilers?:  No/Very Minor
Volumes: Omnibus 3, 6 altogether

Goodreads Synopsis:


Kidnapped by a handsome man with rabbit ears, Alice Liddell finds herself abandoned in an odd place called Wonderland and thrust into a "game," the rules of which she has yet to learn. Alice, ever the plucky tomboy, sets off to explore and get the lay of this strange land, intent on finding her rude kidnapper and giving him a piece of her mind (and her fist). But little does she know that she's wandered right into the middle of a dangerous power struggle involving just about all of Wonderland's attractive, weapon-happy denizens. And the only way for Alice to return home is to get acquainted with the lot of them?! How in the world will she manage that and still manage to stay alive?!


Available on Amazon.

Review:

Firstly, I’m not going to be comparing this series to the original Alice in Wonderland much. (1) Because I just don’t care about the similarities all that much and I’m not really looking for any, or noticing them, aside from maybe a very obvious same plot line or same character. And (2), because they are very different. This story, from the beginning, took a different route, took the story in a different direction. And I realize that some people are very picky about that, and don’t like this series because of things like that, but I was honestly pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this volume.
I found this story interesting when I first heard about, and tried reading it once but I think I just mostly wasn’t in the mood for it. I’d planned to pick it up at some point, but I didn’t, and then Tokyopop went down, and I still didn’t. But then Yen Press picked it up, and I found it for a really good price online and got it. After reading the first book, I’m glad I did, because I really enjoyed it.
So the book starts with Alice waking up from a dream that mentioned some kind of game, and, as expected, she’s sleeping on the grass as her sister reads a book next to her. Psychology is mentioned, and her sister tells her about the book she’s reading, which is, of course, Alice in Wonderland. And then her sister leaves to get some cards for them to play, and Alice proceeds to fall asleep again. She wakes up when a clothed rabbit goes past, but when she tries to fall back asleep, the rabbit comes back to wake her up, claiming she is supposed to follow him, and then picking her up and bringing her with him down the rabbit hole.
When they get there, he kisses her in order to make her drink some kind of liquid that enforces she play part in some game, and makes it so she has to finish before going back home. She’s confused, and angry at the rabbit, and we later find out that the glass the liquid came from will slowly refill the farther in the game she gets, and once it’s completely filled up, she can go home.
She ends up staying at the clock tower with Julius, the clock maker/fixer, who tells her about Wonderland (the town is actually called the Country of Hearts, I believe, but  I’m going to be calling it Wonderland). Apparently there’s some kind of feud going on between the three different parts of the town, the Heart Castle, where the rabbit Peter White and the Queen Vivaldi and Ace reside, the Amusement Park, where the Cheshire cat Boris and (Mary) Gowland live, and the Hatter Mansion, where the hatter Blood Dupre and Elliot March and the Bloody Twins (Dee and Dum) live. The clock tower, where Julius lives and Alice is staying, is neutral land.
While in this ‘dream’, Alice also sleeps and dreams, and in her dreams, she meets Nightmare, who tells her some things about the world and why she’s there and some things about herself. Including that everyone in Wonderland is going to love her, and that this world is of her making. This makes her wonder if they’re falling in love with her because she wants them to, and is she really that self-centered? From there, I really enjoy her little musings about the world.
This Wonderland is very interesting. The time changes at random, turns daylight and dark at any time, and, much like the cards in the original, all of the helpers at each place have no face and are easily replaced. Everyone, really, is easily replaced, and people are always getting killed. I won’t spoil too much more about that, because there are these afterimages, and things get done with the bodies and their ‘hearts’ that were a bit of a surprise and is causing a controversy in their world, and I don’t want to spoil too much.
There are several guys, all of whom are supposedly falling in love with Alice, and I’m interested to see what happens with that, especially since some of them are fighting already and Alice is causing some jealous feelings to erupt. At this point, I’m not sure who I want her to be with, either. I’m thinking that the Hatter, Blood Dupre, is the obvious choice, but I also quite like Ace, and there’s something about the cheshire Boris that I like as well… I’m not sure where my feelings about them all are going at this point, but I’m looking forward to finding out.
Also, I am happy to say that I do like Alice. She’s just curious enough, and she’s also very kind and is always trying to stop everyone from killing each other, and I like how she thinks about everything. She’s wondering if all of it is her making, and what that means about her, and she kind of wants no part in any of this, but she’s obviously getting a bit attached and is going to end up too deep in all of it. She’s also a bit feisty; she sticks up for what she believes in, and when she doesn’t like something or someone (like the rabbit Peter) she lets them know.
There are some dark things brewing, between each area and some possible scandalizing things happening behind closed doors. Also, some of the people in this world are representing people from Alice’s real world, including her sister and her sister’s boyfriend (who is also the guy that Alice likes), which is obviously going to cause some drama. As is the fact that everyone is growing to love her but she can only choose one, and only for the amount of time that she’s there. Unless, of course, something neat happens to change that, which I hope does happen. Oh, and at the beginning we’re introduced to some kind of game she’s inadvertently become a part of, one of the rules including that when she leaves, she has to take someone with her, I think?. I’m hoping to hear more about that in the next book, since not much of what the game actually is was explained.
I mentioned above that I’m not going to compare much, and how this is so different from the original, and it is. There are similarities in the characters, but they are very different people, and they even look quite different. For instance, the Cheshire and the march hare and the rabbit are human, but with cat/bunny ears. The Cheshire cat is the most different in that respect, and his personality is as well. He’s much more adorable, and doesn’t seem to know everything about everyone quite as much.
I liked Alice in Wonderland, and enjoy most forms that it’s told, and I’m enjoying this one a lot, but I’m always very wary of the stories. Because, while I’m getting wrapped up in the story and falling for the characters, I have to remember that Alice wakes up at some point, and, in most versions, she doesn’t bring any of the characters with her. So, whatever happens while in Wonderland, she has to leave it all behind. I’m thinking that maybe the person she really falls for she will get to be with when she wakes, but I’m still unsure and very wary.
I’m rather looking forward to the next book, now.
Oh, as a sidenote: the covers. I think the covers are very pretty, and the artwork is also very nice; the artwork isn’t overly flowy or gorgeous, but it is very nice and detailed and I like looking at it; the outfits are especially nice. And I think how the covers are turned to the side is neat. But the fact that the covers are turned to the side, and the back cover looks like it’s upside down to me, makes me disoriented, and almost every time I pick it up, it’s upside down. I’m not quite sure why this is, but it is disorienting and that’s bothers me, even while I do like the idea; maybe it’s just me?
Also, I remember mentioning in one of my other omnibus review that it looked like the publisher(/editor/whoever) put little to no effort into making the two books look like one, in that when the first book ended, it (I think?) said some version of ‘to be continued’ and had copyright pages before moving into the next book, and that bothered me a tiny bit. I was happy to see that this volume was different from that. I could tell when one volume ended, but only because the chapter ended slightly different from the others at the halfway point, but there wasn’t too much of a difference or pause between chapters, and I liked that, and there was also an index at the beginning of the book for the whole two volumes, and I liked that. I mean, it’s not really that big of a deal, I guess, but I like that fact that it shows the publisher made more of an effort than just printing the two books in one binding.